The $5,499 Reserve was too firm after a month, so she prefers the $1,199 Costco version.
Quick note: Some links are affiliate links. We earn a tiny commission if you buy (at no cost to you). Keeps the lights on!
64signal
17reviews34% Positive33% Mixed33% Negative
Owners mostly find it comfortable, with several happy after months or years.
What sleepers love, and what they don’tWhat sleepers noticed
Liked
Watch for
Also mentioned: firmer than expected2returned it2softer than expected1
Sleeper reviews (17)
Showing 5 reviews mentioning too firm Show all
The 17-inch Firm Euro Pillow Top felt good initially, but grew uncomfortable and stayed too firm over time even after modifying the top layers and adding toppers.
The Reserve pillow top firm is a tiny bit too firm for this side sleeper but slowly breaking in and very substantial
Even after a 30-day break-in, the Pillowtop Soft still felt firm rather than plush and the tufted buttons poked through a mattress pad, leading to a return.
The firm pillow top was sold as a medium but gives hip, shoulder and knee pain, so it is being returned
Common questions about Stearns & Foster Reserve
What do sleepers say about Stearns & Foster Reserve?
Owners mostly find it comfortable, with several happy after months or years. A few found the firmer versions too firm for their hips or shoulders.
Is Stearns & Foster Reserve worth it?
Of the 15 reviews with a clear verdict, 33% are positive, 33% mixed and 33% negative. The praise mentioned most is comfortable. The most common complaint is too firm.
What do people like about Stearns & Foster Reserve?
The praise reviewers mention most: comfortable (6 reviews), held up well (2 reviews) and deep pockets (1 review). For example: Six months in the soft pillow top suits sensitive hips and gives back support after four other mattresses
What are the most common complaints about Stearns & Foster Reserve?
The complaints reviewers mention most: too firm (5 reviews), overpriced (2 reviews) and took long to break in (1 review). For example: The firm pillow top was sold as a medium but gives hip, shoulder and knee pain, so it is being returned
What does the signal score of 64 mean?
It's how well reviewed Stearns & Foster Reserve is, out of 100, next to the other mattresses here. Two things go in: how its reviews compare with the best-reviewed product (positive reviews, mixed counting half, and how many reviews there are), and its own negative and mixed reviews, which take points off, so only a product few people are unhappy with scores in the high 90s. It's worked out from reviews only, needs at least 5 of them, and updates as new ones come in.
What are the specs of Stearns & Foster Reserve?
Category: Mattress. Type: Innerspring. Firmness: Medium, Soft, Firm. Height: 16–17 in. Notable features: Reserve collection luxury innerspring.
Where do these Stearns & Foster Reserve reviews come from?
17 are quotes from Reddit, each linked to the original. Sleeper reviews are checked for spam before they appear. Every review, written here or quoted, is read as positive, mixed or negative.
