Reddit · r/BuyItForLife · 8 days ago
Over a year in, it stays cool and is heavy enough to feel good, and the eucalyptus claim is not just hype. It holds up great in the wash.
Home/Reviews
Latest reviews
Fresh experiences from real sleepers, collected from Reddit, YouTube and blogs and linked to their sources.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 9 days ago
Over a year with the bamboo sheets and a linen quilt as a hot sleeper; the smooth cooling texture was missed after switching to Quince linen sheets for winter. The Quince return policy is described as great.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 9 days ago
Wonderful softness and comfort, but the fitted sheet wore threadbare and shredded after five years despite rotating half the time with another sheet set.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 12 days ago
One-year-old bamboo cooling sheets used year-round by an extremely hot sleeper in the south. The fitted sheet's corners are already roughed up and shaggy, as if cut with a razor blade, but the bamboo is still liked.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 25 days ago
Found the percale sheets terrible: after one wash they pilled all over and felt scratchy and thin.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 26 days ago
Hot sleeper who has used their two sets of Boll & Branch signature sheets since 2019; they improved with washing and settled into a soft yet structured feel.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 28 days ago
The percale sheets come out of the dryer very wrinkly but are great to sleep on for a hot sleeper, though it has only been a few months.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 28 days ago
Loves the percale sheets, which turned super soft after a vinegar wash while a department store set stayed rough.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 34 days ago
Five years in the down duvet insert is still fluffy and warm, though the matching cover wore out sooner
Reddit · r/Bedding · 34 days ago
The lightweight Brooklinen keeps them warm enough in California and she has been happy with it so far
Reddit · r/Bedding · 40 days ago
Loved their Cozy Earth sheets for softness until holes appeared, finding them soft but not very durable.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 41 days ago
They own Quince bamboo sheets and find them the softest, most luxurious sheets they have, though on their cooled mattress they feel icy at first.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 44 days ago
Their last two Brooklinen percale sheet sets wore unevenly and then split, which was disappointing, though their first set is still great.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 44 days ago
They are returning the Brooklinen luxe sateen they just bought because it turned scratchy and pilled after a single wash.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 46 days ago
Over two years of use, the soft, sheeny feel on the skin and cooling performance have been great, though queen color options have been pared down.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 46 days ago
The Purple sheets lasted about six years, outlasting a cheap Amazon replacement that pilled badly
Reddit · r/Bedding · 52 days ago
Cotton sateen from this brand felt soft and velvety out of the box and was loved, even by a fabric-sensitive owner. Only discontinued colors prompted a switch to another brand.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 53 days ago
Way too stiff, light, and rough for someone with sensory sensitivity to scratchy fabrics.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 61 days ago
Several queen sets over the years delivered unbeatable softness, breathability, and quality, though recent price increases of nearly 100 dollars pushed them out of budget.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 67 days ago
Owns three sets and keeps buying them
Reddit · r/Bedding · 68 days ago
After years of sheets slipping off, the Purple set has not come off once
Reddit · r/Bedding · 70 days ago
Owns percale sheets, pillowcases and duvet covers from Boll & Branch bought on sale and loves them, still in good condition after five years of constant laundering.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 70 days ago
Owns Signature Hemmed sheets from Boll & Branch alongside Ralph Lauren ones, and their spouse always comments that these are the nice sheets.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 75 days ago
A few years in, it's fine washed on cool and tumble dried on low. The matching pillows aren't good though and need to be higher quality.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 84 days ago
Very thin in a cheap way with a paper-like feel compared to Charter Club.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 89 days ago
Zero issues after four years of weekly washing and alternating with another percale set.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 90 days ago
Great percale sheets across two sets when washed on cold before use according to instructions.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 105 days ago
Owns three sets of the signature hem sheets from Boll and Branch and finds them soft, getting softer with every wash.
Reddit · r/BuyItForLife · 105 days ago
Percale are the best cooling sheets found, despite other Brooklinen issues.
Reddit · r/BuyItForLife · 107 days ago
Classic percale sheets with no problems.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 112 days ago
Felt almost too worn on arrival, and though really soft, lacked the smooth, silky feel of the Macy's Hotel Collection sheets they were replacing.
Reddit · r/BuyItForLife · 124 days ago
Still has all four percale sheet sets bought 8 to 10 years ago with no issues, though she has heard newer ones are not the same
Reddit · r/BuyItForLife · 124 days ago
Two years in the sateen sheets start to tear, matching what others in the thread reported
Reddit · r/BuyItForLife · 124 days ago
Both Parachute linen sets thinned and ripped within about a year and a half, so she will not buy their linen sheets again
Reddit · r/Bedding · 125 days ago
Has used Brooklinen percale since about 2017 and ordered more; the fitted sheet fits tightly and feels good after washing, with a couple of small holes after several years.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 128 days ago
Bought the Brooklinen percale set a month earlier and loves it, acknowledging others find it a bit papery but liking it themself.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 131 days ago
Not a fan of the linen sheets, preferring a nice older Company Store set and The Citizenry.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 138 days ago
Had Brooklinen sateen sheets that ripped in under a year while a Hudson Park set has lasted through harsh washing.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 138 days ago
Very soft, luxurious feel with attractive plain color options that make it worth buying another set when budget allows.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 144 days ago
They enjoy their Buffy comforter with its duvet cover for his hot sleeping, but it is dry clean only, which isn't practical with a dog and young kids
Reddit · r/Bedding · 146 days ago
Pleasant percale sheet set to sleep on, though L.L.Bean percale sheets remain an even bigger favorite.
Reddit · r/quince · 148 days ago
Bamboo sheets were great for a period of time, but the bamboo bedding slides too much and cotton is preferred.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 154 days ago
Percale is overpriced and underwhelming.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 154 days ago
Percale felt like sandpaper and was returned for LL Bean.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 155 days ago
Luxe sateen wonderful for years and cooler than other brands.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 155 days ago
Percale are okay and soft but make a weird sound.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 155 days ago
Sateen scratchy at first but improved after numerous washes.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 155 days ago
Disappointed by Luxe sateen for the price.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 156 days ago
Percale was extremely scratchy; swapped for Target percale.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 156 days ago
Loves the percale, though quality may have slipped.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 156 days ago
Absolutely loves the percale sheets.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 156 days ago
Percale was scratchy out of the package but softer after one wash.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 156 days ago
A new percale set is dreamy and not scratchy.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 165 days ago
Owns the bamboo sheets and loves them, calling them very soft with deep pockets that fit their thick mattress.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 165 days ago
Fell in love with the bamboo sheets, bought a second set, and after a year and a half they still look and feel new.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 165 days ago
Owns the bamboo sheets plus a cotton quilt and loves them.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 166 days ago
Bought the Giza cotton sateen sheets after returning the linen ones, is very happy, and uses them more than their Boll and Branch set.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 166 days ago
Has two sets of the percale sheets that have been amazing for over two years.
Reddit · r/laundry · 170 days ago
Loved the percale sheets, though the care tag calls for cold-water washing and Quince has not explained why.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 174 days ago
Owns a few sets of white sheets including Cozy Earth and prefers the Cozy Earth ones for being silkier and thicker.
Reddit · r/BuyItForLife · 176 days ago
Significantly softer and quieter than an IKEA down comforter and still good after a couple of years
Reddit · r/Bedding · 177 days ago
Finds the Boll & Branch signature sheets insanely soft and is hooked on the brand despite snags on their waffle blanket.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 186 days ago
The ultralight Tencel set traps way too much heat, unlike Casper's cotton sheets
Reddit · r/Bedding · 203 days ago
Received a Cozy Earth bamboo sheet set with loose threads and sloppy seams, then had a frustrating return and warranty experience.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 203 days ago
Newly received percale sheets felt too rough, not the crisp, cool finish wanted as a replacement for 15-year-old Ralph Lauren cotton sheets.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 203 days ago
Pilling started developing after only about two weeks of owning the sheets.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 208 days ago
Cool, breathable cotton percale weave made a dramatic improvement for hot sleeping compared to standard retail cotton sheets.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 221 days ago
Pilled on both the top and bottom sheets after just two weeks and two washes, and customer service never followed through on a replacement or refund.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 223 days ago
Heavy, smooth two-ply percale with a luxurious feel and the deepest pockets of five brands tried, though the bottom sheet needed adjusting most mornings on a 13-inch mattress and it held more heat, so it suits winter.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 223 days ago
Thin, cool, and crisp long-staple cotton that fits well without shifting, though the weave has a lot of texture even after several washes and they would not order it again.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 226 days ago
Two pairs of Breeze sheets were very soft and the best at temperature regulation, and they were still in great condition after years.
Reddit · r/Bedding · 229 days ago
Obsessed with them. The elastic is amazing, they're nice and thick, and they've lasted years and years.